The 8% Rule: What Analyzing 1,500 Newsletters Taught Me About Exponential Substack Growth
"Are you seriously still working? It's midnight."
My husband stood in the doorway, concern etched across his face as he surveyed the chaos of my home office. Spreadsheets everywhere. Three empty coffee mugs. Printouts of Substack posts arranged in mysterious patterns on the floor.
"I'm onto something big," I said, my eyes never leaving the screen. "Give me another hour."
That was 2 weeks ago. What started as casual research had turned into a full-blown obsession: understanding why some newsletters explode while others plateau.
This edition is brought to you by EmailTooltester
Struggling to pick the right newsletter platform?
Don’t waste hours comparing tools.
This free comparison template breaks down the top 5 newsletter platforms—features, pricing, and everything you need to make the best choice.
✔️ Find the best tool to grow & monetize
✔️ Get a tailored recommendation from experts
✔️ No more guesswork—just the right fit for you
Wanna get your service or brand in front of 46K creators? Book your brand deal here.
The Obsession Begins
It all started with a simple question: Why did my subscriber count nearly double when pregnancy forced me to publish less frequently?
The conventional wisdom—publish consistently, stick to a niche, use good headlines—wasn't explaining the dramatic difference I was seeing.
So I did what any slightly neurotic, data-driven creator would do: I went down the rabbit hole.
I tracked 1,500 newsletters across various niches for 90 days. I analyzed their:
Publishing frequency
Content types
Headline patterns
Growth rates
Free-to-paid conversion
Engagement metrics
The results shocked me so much that I built an entire system (more on Substackulous later) to implement what I discovered.
The 8/92 Rule That Changes Everything
Here's the finding that kept me up until 3 AM that night:
92% of Substack growth comes from just 8% of content types.
Let that sink in.
Most creators are spinning their wheels producing content that—while perfectly fine—will never drive meaningful growth.
The newsletters experiencing exponential rather than linear growth weren't just executing the basics better. They were playing an entirely different game.
The Growth Patterns Nobody Talks About
What exactly was in that magical 8%? It wasn't what I expected.
It wasn't breaking news. It wasn't how-to guides. It wasn't even personal stories (though those help with retention).
The content driving explosive growth shared one surprising quality: it made readers pick sides.
Not through divisiveness or manufactured controversy. But through clear, unambiguous positions on topics their audience cared about.
Examples from my research:
A finance newsletter stopped sharing "10 stocks to consider" and instead published "Why I'm betting my retirement on these 3 stocks (and selling everything else)"
A parenting newsletter abandoned "different approaches to screen time" in favor of "I let my kids have unlimited screen time for 30 days, and it transformed our relationship"
A productivity writer quit the "here are various morning routines" posts and committed to "Why I believe morning routines are a scam designed to make you feel inadequate"
The pattern was clear:
The "here's both sides, you decide" posts generated crickets.
The "here's where I stand and why" posts? Growth explosions.
My Accidental Experiment
Remember when I mentioned how pregnancy forced me to cut back my publishing schedule?
What I didn't tell you was that it also made me less interested in being "balanced" and "covering all angles."
With limited energy and time, I found myself writing with more conviction. More certainty. More willingness to plant a flag and say "this is what I believe."
My headlines shifted from: "Various Ways to Grow Your Newsletter"
To: "The Newsletter Growth Strategy That Works in 2025 (And Why Everything Else Fails)"
The results were immediate and dramatic:
Email forwards increased by 217%
Social shares jumped by 143%
New subscriber conversion shot up by 88%
In my recent mastermind (where I coach creators on monetization strategies), I started testing this approach with members. Those who shifted from balanced, comprehensive content to strong positions saw similar growth spikes.
The Psychological Trigger
Why does this work?
In a world drowning in nuanced, balanced content, a clear position becomes a life raft of certainty. People don't subscribe to newsletters for more information—they have Google for that.
They subscribe for clarity. For someone to help them make sense of the information they already have access to.
Every "here's my clear stance" post triggers a psychological response:
Agreement: "Yes! I've always thought this but couldn't articulate it!"
Disagreement: "What? I need to see how they justify this position."
Curiosity: "Hmm, I've never considered this perspective before."
All three responses drive engagement. Only indifference kills growth.
How to Apply This Insight (Without Becoming a Jerk)
Now, I'm not suggesting you adopt extreme positions just for attention. That's the realm of shock jocks and tabloids.
What I am suggesting is that you stop diluting your actual beliefs in an attempt to please everyone.
Here's how to apply the 8% rule:
1. Identify Your Actual Position
What do you genuinely believe about your subject matter that others might disagree with? What have you learned through experience that contradicts conventional wisdom?
When I analyzed my own beliefs about newsletter growth, I realized I strongly believed that:
Most creators publish too frequently
Premium newsletters should publish less, not more
Strong positioning beats better writing
Substack tags are wildly underutilized growth levers
Each of these became high-converting content.
2. State Your Position Clearly in Headlines
Compare these headlines:
"Thoughts on Publishing Frequency"
"Publishing Daily Is Killing Your Newsletter: Why Less Content Drives More Growth"
Which would you click?
3. Back Your Position with Evidence
Strong positions without supporting evidence come across as mere opinions. The magic happens when you combine a bold stance with compelling data and examples.
This is exactly what I teach in my newsletter monetization mastermind: evidence-based conviction sells better than balanced comprehensiveness.
4. Acknowledge Counterarguments (Then Explain Why You Still Disagree)
This shows intellectual honesty without weakening your position.
It demonstrates you've considered multiple angles and still arrived at your conclusion.
How I Built This Into Substackulous
After discovering these patterns, I realized most creators needed a system to identify what positions would resonate with their specific audience.
That's why I spent three months building Substackulous, which includes:
The Home Run: Analyzes any Substack to identify what content triggers growth spikes
Click-Worthy Title Maker: Transforms your positions into headlines that force readers to pick sides
Viral Notes Generator: Creates Notes designed to drive positioning-based engagement
One early Substackulous user analyzed their previous content and discovered their mild, balanced posts averaged 4-7 new subscribers, while their rare strong-position posts averaged 35-50 new subscribers.
After implementing this insight consistently, their growth rate tripled in just 45 days.
The Contrarian Case Study
Let me share one final story that demonstrates the power of this approach.
In my mastermind, we had a creator who wrote about personal finance. He published comprehensive, balanced articles covering multiple approaches to investing, saving, and financial planning.
His growth had plateaued at about 60-80 new subscribers monthly for over a year.
During one session, I challenged him: "What do you actually believe about investing that might be controversial?"
After some hesitation, he admitted he thought most people should avoid individual stock picking entirely and use only low-cost index funds—even though teaching stock analysis would make him more money.
I encouraged him to write a post titled: "Why I'll Never Pick Individual Stocks Again (And Why I Think You Shouldn't Either)"
He was nervous about alienating readers who enjoyed his stock analysis. But he wrote it anyway.
That single post brought in 470 new subscribers (in one week)—more than his previous two months combined.
More importantly, his paid conversion rate jumped from 2.1% to 3.7%, because people who shared his investment philosophy were more likely to value his premium content.
Your Growth Breakthrough Awaits
Let me leave you with this:
The most successful newsletters aren't the most comprehensive or even the best-written. They're the ones that help readers form or reinforce their own positions in a confusing world.
Your breakthrough growth post isn't the one that covers all angles. It's the one where you finally stop hedging and plant your flag firmly in the ground.
What strong position have you been afraid to take? What conviction have you been diluting? What's your stake in the ground?
That's where your growth lives.
For Paid Subscribers: Tag Strategy Workshop Access
Speaking of taking positions, one of my strongest beliefs is that Substack tags are the most underutilized growth lever on the platform. When used strategically, they can boost discovery by up to 327%.
I recently ran a workshop breaking down my complete system for using tags to dramatically accelerate growth. This workshop normally sells for $97, but it's available to all paid subscribers at no additional cost.
Upgrade to Paid Membership to Access the Tags Workshop Now